Lebanon Once Again at a Crossroads

While debates were still underway in Beirut’s presidential palace over whether Hezbollah’s disarmament should even be on the agenda, the spokesperson of the Iran-backed militia, Naim Kassim, appeared on television. “We cannot accept that Lebanon gradually gives up its strength while all the cards remain in the hands of the Israeli enemy,” he declared.
Despite Hezbollah’s resistance, the government adopted a roadmap: by the end of August, the army must present a plan outlining which weapons will be collected and when. By year’s end, Hezbollah should no longer possess rockets or mortars, Prime Minister Nawaf Salam announced. In protest, Hezbollah’s ministers demonstratively walked out of the session.
For Lebanon, such disarmament would mark a historic step – for the first time in four decades, the state could reclaim its monopoly on the use of force. Many citizens support the plan, especially since Hezbollah once held up to 150,000 rockets. Yet for now, these remain only words. Whether the militia will truly surrender its arsenal is uncertain.
Observers in Beirut envision several scenarios: renewed Israeli strikes followed by Hezbollah retaliation, the outbreak of another civil war – or perhaps nothing at all, which would likely suit the militia best.
Founded in resistance to Israel’s occupation (1982–2000), Hezbollah has always refused to give up its weapons. Instead, it turned them against domestic rivals. For Tehran, it long served as the cornerstone of the so-called “Axis of Resistance.” But since the death of leader Hassan Nasrallah in autumn 2024, the organisation has been but a shadow of its former self.
After suffering heavy losses, Hezbollah recently agreed to a fragile ceasefire with Israel – a deal it views as little short of capitulation. In parts of southern Lebanon, it has already handed over weapons to the army. Kassim insists, however, that disarmament can only begin once Israel withdraws its border positions.
Newly elected President Joseph Aoun pledged in January to restore the state’s monopoly on force – but only through dialogue with Hezbollah. Talks over the past months have gone nowhere. Many Lebanese, especially Christians and Sunnis, have long since lost patience with the militia. Even many Shiites accuse it of dragging them into a war that has brought nothing but destruction. Tehran no longer provides compensation, and entire villages lie in ruins.
The US, Europe, and the Gulf states have tied financial aid to Hezbollah’s disarmament. But there are no guarantees that Israel would halt its strikes in return.
In this process, the European Union has positioned itself above all as a mediator. Brussels points to UN Resolution 1701 and stresses that only gradual, consensus-driven disarmament can bring lasting stability. European diplomats warn that a forced move could endanger Lebanon’s fragile balance rather than secure it. Instead, the EU pushes for dialogue among all Lebanese factions and has pledged reconstruction and reform aid – but only once tangible progress is visible. Europe thus presents itself less as a source of pressure and more as a potential guarantor of a political solution.
Hezbollah now faces a stark dilemma: rejecting disarmament risks civil war and isolation, while accepting it could trigger internal splits, as hardliners vow never to compromise. Many Shiites still view the weapons as the guarantor of their community’s place in Lebanon’s fragile sectarian balance.
The militia’s reaction to the government’s decision was characteristically defiant: it would treat the measure as if it did not exist. It is the familiar tactic – playing for time, hoping the storm will pass.
Whether this time will be different remains unclear. Lebanon’s foreign minister sounded resolute: “This decision is final and irreversible.” Many Lebanese can only hope he is right.


